PeterE wrote:
But a major problem on this issue is that public transport seems to demand such enormous amounts of subsidy from the taxpayer, whereas private transport pays for itself many times over.
Yes and no. Some of the train operating companies do make a profit and return money to the government, and it's no suprise thay they are the ones who run effiecent and attrative services. The lines that need proping up are the ones that provide, unsuprisingly, a service that nobody wants. If it's infrequent, unreliable with poor provisions for parking as well as expensive fares it's no shock that nobody wants to use it.
My belief is that it's desirable to spend money to create services people
want to use. Not forced to, not kicked out of their cars, but pro-actively choose the train. Public transport does offer benefits. No matter how good a motorway network is provided, there is still the problem of parking at the other end. The train will take you into the heart of the city and the fare can be less then cost of parking at bigger cities.
prof Beard wrote:
I think it is a real pity that many who are "pro-motorist" seem to be anti public transport, and equal sadly most who are pro public transport seem anti-car. I believe that a properly integrated public transport system is a desirable, if not essential, feature of an efficient and modern society, and that done properly it should improve the motorists lot rather than degrade it - and that its presence should make a positive impact on road safety. And the moment by viewing public transport and the car as "enemies" we are just compounding the half-arsed policy thinking we are getting all too used to
I try as best I can to be positive to the role that public transport can play while at the same time recongnising that it can never replace the car, and car use should not be 'frowned' upon as it is by some groups. I enjoy using my car and don't feel guilty about it but if there is practical and affordable public transport alternative I will usually choose it. Sometimes though, I take the car simply because I fancy the drive.