B cyclist wrote:
Johnnytheboy wrote:
Far more tax is collected from motorists than is spent on the roads, use some of that.
I'm afraid that is unproven.
Besides, do you really have a wish to turn the UK's Tax Regime upside down?
e.g. Old people hardly contribute any tax, yet they cost billions. I say we should take the money away from the old people and give it to the people that pay. The ones that pay are the ones that deserve it!!
See, even if you are right on the tax amount, it isn't as simplistic as that.
If you want to go into it, old people have paid tax all their lives. They still pay tax on their income, even if it is from a pension.
They have paid into the welfare system since it started.
If you really wish to contribute insulting comments then contribute them towards the pensioners who paid nothing for their pensions...index linked and income based. Public servants.
Taxation from motorists:
* Motorists in the UK pay £42.2 billion to the Government in taxation: fuel tax £22.1 billion; Vehicle Excise Duty £4.6 billion; VAT on vehicles £6.8 billion; VAT on fuel £5.6 billion and company car tax £3.1 billion
* In addition, motorists pay another £75.2 billion into the economy through their purchase of vehicles, fuel and basic running costs
* Just £6.7 billion was spent on UK roads infrastructure in 2003
* 92 per cent of all passenger travel is by road
* 6.5 per cent is by rail
* Roads serve 92 per cent of our travel needs
* Britain’s major road network has increased by just 0.06 per cent (under 200 miles/316kms) in 10 years
* Our motorway network ranks among the least developed in Europe (motorway network length to unit of GDP). The UK is fourteenth out of a European league table of 15 - only Ireland has fewer miles
Spending on roads, maintenance and repair:
About £6/7 billion
The real problem facing the country NOW, is the cost of providing pensions for public servants.
Even when deductions are made from salaries they are not invested in anything, those deductions just go to paying those already retired.
The cost of government pensions NOW is £1,000,000,000,000. That is, the cost of paying pensions to the CURRENTLY WORKING public servants and those ALREADY retired.
Fan. Hitting. Shit. The.
So, within 30 years....all the taxation will be needed to pay retirement pensions for government employees.
A bit simplistic ?
You completely miss the point of my comparison. Mind you it did allow you to rant a bit!
There is no connection in the country's Tax regime between monies paid in by sections of society and monies paid out. There is I think, one exception, which is the 1% extra NI that goes to the NHS.
Even if your figures on taxes vs. spend on roads were right (and you'll probably know that you've only looked at one aspect of road spending - which does rather help your argument) it would make no difference. We don't give back taxpayers the exact money they have paid out. That would be a bit silly, wouldn't it!