This rather brings us into line with mainland EU - or rather France, Germany, Austria who all have "formal tuition" as compulsory and whose tests do include an "attitude" one. The "attitude" one is a rather recent one for France. I gather Germany and Austria introduced one such component some three years ago. (Source - German equivalent of "Auto Car"

.
I am not sure I agree with the "graduated licence" idea. I want to know exactly what restrictions would be proposed given we live in a rural area and my three young drivers are on these roads as a matter of need

I also would not like to see these kids restricted from carrying passengers amongst their own circle of pals either - as I see this as a part of their independence and growing up. I would, however, expect the "attitude" test to have identified those pre-disposed to some "red mist" and some correcting rein-in during the formal lessons.
As said in the past - our kids have had lots of cycling experience, some karting experience to get idea of handling skills and a feel of speed

Two years before "becoming of age to learn this skill" - we started to make them more aware of the roads, hazard perception skills, knowledge of the Highway Code - along with some fun DVD stuff from the local computer shoppe (DSA WHAT IF? DVD - was actually very useful but sadly "predictable" at times

)
We then booked their first lessons in blocks of 6 daily lessons at varying times - including "peak rush"

. Once they had these under thier belt - we supervised practice sessions. We then booked another 6 lessons or more if we felt this needed - to hone and tone for the driving test as like any exam - the teachers train specifically to get the pass
After they passed - and these three did so on the first attempt - we did not allow any driving for 24 hours as we thought they needed to calm down from the excitement and high spirits
We then kept up the drives under our supervision for a few days and then discreetly followed their first solo drives. Heck .. I want to know they are safe enough after all

We (me and my wife Wildy

) then took them on supervised motorway drives with us as passengers. I think our eldest (Wills) was the most nervous on his first "outing". Our eldest daughter was slightly "nervous" whilst her twin brother - Nick - predictably was completely unfazed by anything.

- including Place Charles de Gaulle in Paris. (I admit this was sheer cruelty on my part

but he trumped me out in this. I wanted to see him squirm but he didn't.

This guy is 100% his Mother's son

- Well you have to blame someone

)
I think much does depend on education.. moral values, manners, courtesy, ethics. We reap what we sow after all.
