cotswold wrote:
Nothing beats using the money for good, old fashioned, bib's on the ground.
Shame that Bib are not self funding then isn't it...
Oh! Isn't there a very good reason for that? If they were self funding then it would strongly encourage abuses of the system based on financial targets, and concepts such as justice, fairness, respect, etc. go out of the window, and we would then quickly create a system where the law enforcement agency becomes on the spot judge, jury and executioner.
Perhaps the lack of pro-camera posts reflect not so much on the use of cameras in a few key locations, but the growing disquiet at the widespread blatant abuse of them and the associated loss of basic rights, such as the right not to incriminate yourself.
Everything about them is wrong once you get beyond the childlike headlines, and after a few posts most open minded and intelligent people quickly realise that they are trying to defend the indefensable. Safe Speed is very keen on finding somebody who can give a good rational argument for them, and Motorcycle News has even offered £1M for a convincing justification that will stand up to cross-examination, but so far none has appeared.
The simple facts are:
Speed Cameras only catch otherwise fully law abiding drivers that have maintained all the necessary paperwork. They do nothing against unregistered, cloned, stolen, or foreign vehicles.
They only catch vehicles exceeding the posted speed limit, which according to the 1/3 lie was the primary cause of 30% of accidents, then became a contributary factor in 30%, which then comes down to an average of 5% where the speed limit was exceeded. This is about 105 lives per year.
If speed cameras worked then the best they could achieve is a reduction from 3500 killed per year to 3400 killed. But many over the limit deaths involve non-law abiding drivers that are beyond the ability of a camera to address, so even the 100 lives target is unachievable.
They are however causing a major unecessary hazard and distraction for UK drivers that has resulted in the leveling out of the previously continuously reducing KSi figures. Many drivers now place speed camera identifiction as a very high priority and this is what we think is making our roads much more dangerous than before. The ABD argue that the gap between where we are now with road deaths and where we would have been had previous trends continued was over 5500 deaths (in 2003) and obviously increasing.
You may argue with the numbers, but even the DfT admit that their numbers were "misinterpreted" and that only 4.5% of accidents involve vehicles traveling over the posted limit as a primary factor.
Of course you might be asking why no pro-camera people post here...(read the question - basic exam technique).
Some do, but with the eloquent and purely logic based arguments against them quickly realise that the solid foundation from which they argue is in fact quicksand (caused by 1/3 lie and extrapolation from it), and then they have choices:
1) Keep arguing, because it can be fun winding people up - like Basingwork; sorry that should have read providing a necessary counter argument otherwise the forums would die out as everybody all saying the same thing is boring.
2) Convert to the SafeSpeed view (several).
3) Keep trying because their job requires it (not many, and tend to just regurgitate the same rubbish).
4) Shut up and go and find a site that supports their views.
Or perhaps these forums are not easy to find, and if you do find them they can get quite hostile against off-message posters. Personally I think that except with deliberate Trolling the people are friendly, and you have to work very hard at it to get hostile responses.
So perhaps what we need is to take our arguments out of this forum and into others that are pro-camera. The Cumbria SCP one didn't last long - and a continuation is hosted here. Perhaps we should have a section on the BB listing pro-camera BBs that we can join in order to spread the message wider.