For some background to this, you may want to have a read of
this rant I wrote on another forum where I complain that to get from Aylesbury to Liverpool by train takes nearly 6 hours under normal circumstances and is a cold, uncomfortable, unpleasent, experience filled with chavs, smelly people, smokers, diesel fumes and cafe operators with annoying fake french accents.
I was doing this as my car was in for a long repair and someone in Liverpool was lending me a car, tomorrow I return the car and need to make my way back to Aylesbury. The government is continually bleating on about "Integrated Transport" so I figure that I can mix train and bus, perhaps liverpool -> Milton Keynes by train, then a bus to Aylesbury since there is no direct route to Aylesbury from the north, my GF thinks I should just get the train from MK to Tring (which is a bit further south on the A41) and then get her to pick me up, but surely this should be unnecessary as we have "integrated transport" which means I should be able to get from any reasonably populated location to any other reasonably populated location in a reasonable amount of time without excessive waiting at changes and without taking a route that resembles a spirograph that is being operated by comittee.
My goal is to find a route from Liverpool Lime Street to Aylesbury, leaving around lunchtime so I only have to take a half day off work and arriving in enough time to get to the garage before it shuts. The amount of waiting at changes shouldn't be more than 20-25 minutes. Bonus points if the overall journey time is comparable to driving.
Can I find one? Can I buggery.
According to
this PDF there is a bus every half an hour (except between 12:45 and 14:45 were it's only every hour) that takes about 75 minutes or double the time it would take me by car, so the latest I can get in to MK is 15:45
There is a trip I can make (changing at Crewe) that gets me in for 15:44 this is far too close for comfort.
There is a 3 hour train that gets me in for 15:28 but this involves waiting 3 quarters of an hour at Manchester
There is a direct line that leaves 7 minutes earlier than the 3 hour one, this takes less than 2 hours and gets me in for 14:09 at which point I'd have to wait 36 minutes for the bus
The only journey available for the entire working day that doesn't involve enormous waits leaves at 10:15, arriving 12:09 then bus at 12:15, arriving at 13:27. That's it, the only one!
That's almost as quick as my car, which isn't bad going at all. However it is twice the price (after subsidies) than my car is (after subsidising the above shit) and I have to travel at 10:15 If I get a support call that I can't get rid of, I will add an hour and a half to my journey.
So if any pro public transport types are reading, exactly why should we be getting out of our cars again? Public transport is purely the domain of children and those who cannot afford a car, and if anything we should be making efforts to help them out with running a car so that their movements are not restricted by the state.
How about making it a viable alternative, then drivers may choose to use it voluntarily rather than needing to be hit with a big stick, current policy seems to be to try and make the roads just as bad rather than improve the trains and busses so they can compete. I'm sure there's a law against that